Which Is Better Than Oil Or Propane Heating?

When it comes to heating their homes, many residents of Pennsylvania rely on furnaces and boilers that are fueled by heating oil or propane gas.

Both of these fuels are capable of keeping your home warm, and in almost every manner, they will do this task more effectively than an electrically powered system would.

However, whether it is time to replace an older heating system or to build one in a home that has just been constructed, it is beneficial to think about the advantages and disadvantages of each option.

A brief guide to some of the most significant ones is as follows:


Advantages of heating using propane

In most cases, the price per gallon of propane gas is lower than that of heating oil.

Equipment that works on propane is more efficient than equipment that runs on heating oil.

Propane is considered to be a “clean fuel” by the United States government since it does not create a substantial amount of carbon dioxide when it is burnt.

Because propane is a clean-burning fuel, equipment used for heating with propane needs less maintenance and lasts longer than equipment used for heating with oil.

Due to the fact that propane is non-toxic and non-poisonous, it does not harm groundwater or soil in the event that it leaks. Because of this, propane tanks are able to be buried securely and discreetly out of sight.

Instead of venting via a standard chimney, boilers and furnaces that run on propane gas may have their exhaust ducted out through normal pvc pipe installed in the ceiling or the wall.

Because propane tanks may have substantially greater capacity than heating oil tanks, this results in a reduction in the number of deliveries that are required. This also enables consumers to “stock up” on propane gas whenever prices are more favorable.

A single supply of fuel may be utilized to power a variety of appliances, including water heaters and stoves, when propane is used as the fuel source.

Cons of heating using propane

When it comes to heating, propane has a lower btu output per gallon than oil.

Equipment that burns propane often has a higher initial investment cost than heating oil-based systems do.

Because propane may catch fire when exposed to oxygen, certain safety measures are essential for ensuring that the equipment is used in a risk-free manner.

Pros of heating with oil


Heating oil has a larger btu output per gallon and is used up more slowly than propane; as a result, heating your home with heating oil can end up costing you less money, even if the price of a gallon of propane is lower.

The expense of acquiring equipment is often lower.

Cons of heating with oil

Leaks, particularly in older steel-lined heating oil tanks, may be exceedingly expensive to clean up, a price that is often not covered by homeowner’s insurance. Heating oil tanks are subject to leaks, especially older steel-lined ones.

The vast majority of heating oil originates from sources located offshore, which indicates that its price is susceptible to the dynamics of worldwide market and is thus more volatile than propane.


When burnt, heating oil generates a far higher quantity of carbon dioxide gas than propane does.

When compared to propane furnaces, oil furnaces have a more regular requirement for cleaning, which is a service that must be paid for.

Other household equipment, like as water heaters, ovens, and clothes dryers, are often powered by electricity, which is not as efficient as propane. This is the case with the majority of houses that are heated by oil.

What Is the Best Heating Fuel: Propane or Oil?

Propane has advantages over natural gas, but both have their drawbacks.

A greater variety of gadgets may be powered by this cleaner fuel. It’s easy to arrange for delivery, and the price is often lower than that of heating oil. Because it is stored in a liquid state, your propane tank can hold far more fuel.

Finally, if heating oil escapes, it may do serious damage to the environment. If the worst should happen and your gas tank springs a leak, the area surrounding your house is safe.

Comparing the Costs of Oil and Propane

If you’re trying to decide between oil and propane as a home heating fuel, the price tag is probably a major influence. Propane is a far more cost-effective alternative to home heating oil, helping to keep energy expenditures under control despite the volatility of oil prices.

Choose the price plan that best fits your needs and budget from among our many options. And we offer specials and discounts that will make the changeover a breeze.

Plans for the cost of propane fuel allow you to hedge against the risk of unexpectedly high payments by fixing your rate for the term of your plan, much like a fixed mortgage. For the duration of the plan’s 12 months, you can relax knowing exactly how much each propane delivery will cost you.

Plans include both fixed and variable prices, much like mortgage rates. A set price provides consistency and predictability, which is helpful for budgeting purposes.

You might save money over the course of the year with a variable rate since it adjusts to reflect changes in the market. You are free to choose the package that best suits your requirements.

To help you better budget for your propane requirements, we offer an Equal Payment Plan (EPP) in which you pay the same amount each month, independent of seasonal or annual price changes in propane.

The amount you pay is recalculated twice a year based on your actual propane usage, which may be more or less than anticipated. This choice has the potential to facilitate domestic budgeting.

As carbon prices on traditional heating fuels rise, propane becomes a more financially viable alternative. It has fewer negative effects on ecosystems and economic stability.

Don’t forget that getting rid of your oil tank might lower your homeowner’s insurance costs. warm from the propane furnace

Advantages of Changing Over to Propane Fuel from Oil

It’s simpler than you would think to go from using oil to using propane. Our staff at Superior Propane is committed to making sure your conversion goes off without a hitch.

We’ll be there to help you through the whole process, from assessment to installation, so that you have as little downtime as possible. The Switch from Oil to Propane Furnace page details the steps involved in making the change.

We place a premium on making your propane purchase, delivery, and storage as easy as possible. With our cutting-edge gasoline delivery options, such as Automatic Delivery, you’ll never run out again.

This post will teach you everything about making deliveries. Tank monitoring, bill payment, and other services are conveniently available whenever you need them using the mySUPERIOR mobile app or online interface.

Let’s discuss maintenance now. Maintenance for an oil furnace may be difficult and time consuming. The maintenance needs of a propane furnace, on the other hand, may be lower.

Minor maintenance and routine inspections conducted every time you receive a supply of propane should be all that’s required to keep things functioning well. And it means more unwinding and relaxation at home for you.


If you are a client of a heating oil company and have an older heating system and are considering about switching to propane, there are many reasons to make the transition, but it will need careful analysis to determine whether or not it is the best decision for you.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *